Puer Aeternus is Latin for ternal boy. Senex is Latin for old m n. However, this is just one rchetype--a split archetype. Hillman (1970) explains "th t the senex is a complicatio of the p er, infolded into puer structure, so th t puer events are complicated by a s nex background." (p. 146). Explaining that the s nex has a double nature, Hillman c ntinues by saying "one characteristic is n ver safe from inversion into its pposite" (p. 148). So what? How d es all this double talk relate to the r al world?
Since a thorough xamination of the puer is usually ncomplete without discussing its senex counterpart, for the s ke of brevity and focus, the s nex will not be discussed further. The p er will be the focus.
Having b en an inveterate alcoholic/drug addict for m re than 30 years of my l fe, those years can be juxtaposed w th the problem of the puer eternus. I went to a party wh n I was 11 and didn't get b ck until I was, ad extremum--at l st, 43 years old. Indeed, the p er was alive and well in me. H ving spent time in the Augean st bles of county jails and ultimately the st te penitentiary, I noticed that the p er population was alive and well in th re too--a virtual pied-a- terre.
Kipnis (1999) reports studies done by the Pr son Activist Resource Center that lists the top ten r asons for Californians entering prison today:
1. P ssession of a controlled substance
2. P ssession of a controlled substance for s le
3. Robbery
4. Sale of a c ntrolled substance
5. Second-degree burglary
6. Ass ult with a deadly weapon
7. Dr ving under the influence
8. First-degree b rglary
9. Petty theft with a pr or conviction
10. Vehicle theft
Most nmates are imprisoned for substance-related offenses (p. 176). K pnis reminds us that drug offenders r present sixty percent of federal prisoners and ver one-third of state and county pr soners (p. 121). These statistics do not nclude the inmates who are intra m ros--within the walls, because of malesuada f mes--hunger that urges people to crime: cr mes committed to finance drug and lcohol use, or crimes committed while nder the influence, etc. In the n therworld of the prison yard, I f und that most inmates were much l ke me in many ways-- quite c mparable to the scabrous characters whom I ssociated with on the streets.
Marie-Louise von Fr nz (2000) describes me (the puer) as h ving an
arrogant attitude toward ther people due to both an nferiority complex and false feelings of s periority. Such people also usually have gr at difficulty in finding the right k nd of job, for whatever they f nd is never quite right or q ite what they wanted. There is lways 'a hair in the soup' (p. 8).
Lionel C rbett (1997), when addressing narcissism, writes th t "pathological grandiosity which is needed to m intain a fragile self structure may m ke one depreciate the religious values of ther people for the sake of s lf enhancement (p. 34). Not only t ward religious values, I might add, but t ward any values unlike their own.
Me and my puerile friends w re often, to say the least, rresponsible. I am reminded of the t me, under the influence of methamphetamine, I was d gging holes in the desert at an old d mp site. I was so preoccupied w th this frivolous activity that I m de a conscious decision to not go to c urt on a Failure to Appear ch rge. The Peter Pan in me w nted to play instead--trahit sua quemque v luptas, each man's fancy lures him. Acc rding to Kiley (1983)
Victims of the P ter Pan Syndrome can't escape irresponsibility. Th s trap begins as innocent, typical r bellion, but mushrooms into an adult l festyle. A fundamental piece of the p zzle of the Peter Pan Syndrome is gr ss irresponsibility that spawns ineptness in b sic self-care skills (p. 45).
Irresponsibility, a f lse sense of superiority, going from job to j b, not bathing for a week at a t me, and a penchant for blandae m ndacia linguae--the lies of a smooth t ngue, and building air castles are nly some of the quotidian traits of the p er aeternus. This is not to say th t puertraits are all negative. Gauche as the p er is, he is usually very ffable, sanguine, well- intentioned, and good-natured. M ny of his often subtle senex ttributes also enhance the positive puer. His f rebrand presence on prison yards, however, and his ch mical dependency further exacerbates the plight of the n gative puer. So, how might we ccount for such vast numbers of p ople in this country caught in the pr blem of the puer aeternus? One p pular theory is that American youth are v rtually without formal rites of passage--hoc pus, this is the difficulty.
To gnore rites of passage or dismiss th m as trivial or unnecessary rituals is r diculous as denial being a river in Afr ca. Gleaned from The Stanton Peele Add ction Web Site, it is stated th t
in a 1980 article in the Am rican Sociological Review and a 1984 rticle in the Journal of Studies on Alc hol, where two sociologists at the Un versity of Syracuse, Barry Glassner and Br ce Berg, investigating Jewish drinking in a l rge upstate New York city because th y believed that traditionally low Jewish lcoholism rates had increased over the y ars. Of the Jewish people the s ciologists actually interviewed, none had ever had a dr nking problem. Investigating all reports by ctivists in the Jewish community who had nnounced a growing alcoholism problem, Glassner and B rg could not actually locate one J wish alcoholic. Accepting at face values all s ch reports led to calculation of an lcoholism rate of about one-tenth of one p rcent among Jewish adults.
Wow! C uld it be that a bar m tzvah is responsible for this? Probably--at l ast where drugs and alcohol are c ncerned. However, judging by reports from the J wish community, they do have other ddictions such as overeating and anorexia. Acc rding to the National "Jewish Press," R ss (April, 1986) reports that there are s ven to 10 thousand Jewish inmates in the Un ted States. That is not very m ny compared to the two million Am ricans that Kipnis (1999) reports who are b hind bars (p. 170). Under the egis of the church, could initiatory r tes of passage account for the bsence of the puer in Jewish c lture? If so, one could be c mpelled to investigate rites of passage in ther cultures.
"The term initiation," as d fined by Eliade (1958) "in the m st general sense denotes a body of r tes and oral teachings whose purpose is to pr duce a decisive alteration in the r ligious and social status of the p rson to be initiated" (p. x). The cl sest I came to being elevated fr m a child to something more th n a child, was my entrance nto junior high school. Without so m ch as a caveat from the lementary school level, what followed came as a r dical social change. In what seems now l ke an almost overnight transformation, I w nt from a pleasant grade school boy to a cerbic junior high school rebel without a c use: from playing on the monkey b rs to getting drunk at Friday n ght football games; from wrestling with sch olmates on the playground to gang f ghts with rival Mexican gangs after sch ol--riotous, no doubt, as the Germanic b rserkers of antiquity; from playing hide-and-go-seek w th girls to whisking them out of the m vie theater to kiss and fondle th m--not unlike Theseus carrying off Adriadne (p. 109); fr m recess to smoking in the b th rooms during breaks; from evenings h me with parents to malicious mischief w th friends. It could be argued th t there is a nexus between our m licious mischief and the spirit of nitiation. My friends and I felt c mpelled to prove ourselves to each ther, so we acted-out an incredible mount of destructive behavior in the pr cess. This alchemical coniunctio, from boy to w cko, also involved more subtle anomalies. D scussing initiation in Tierra del Fuego, El ade mentions that "a frequent custom is th t of giving the novice a new n me immediately after his initiation (p. 28). S on after my nascent arrival into j nior high school, one of my new fr ends tagged me with the name L ttle Richard. I remained Little Richard for the r st of my first life. My f rst life being my drug and lcohol years; my second life being my p st drug and alcohol years; my pre l fe being a rather short childhood.
The cl sest I came to a formal nitiation ceremony during puberty was my s xth grade graduation ceremony, elevating me to j nior high school status. This happened at bout the same age as the bar m tzvah does in Jewish culture. Being nfamiliar with the bar mitzvah and wh t their ordeals entail, I believe it is s fe to assume that there are p instaking lengths gone to for some k nd of enduring conversion. Eliade (1958) s ys that among the Australian Yuin tr be "the first initiation ceremony, comprising the s paration from the women and the rdeal by fire, is thus complete. Fr m that night on the novices sh re only in the life of the m n"( p.8). Indeed, the elevation to j nior high school with its incumbent s cial status, seemed to suddenly sever an motional attachment to my mother, and cr ated a different kind of emotional ttachment to my newly acquired friends--friends, I m ght add, some of whom I k pt for more than 30 years. In d scussing "the secret society of the B khimba in Mayombe," Eliade shares that "th initiatory ordeals continue from two to f ve years (p. 75).
When c nsidering my adolescence, I could say th t my initiatory ordeals, or rather my nitiatory gradations, also continued for years; th reby eventuating the problem of the p er aeternus. After my elevation to j nior high, I could not bear the nterminable passage of time to arrive at Xv rnah--that light of glory that the m gical age of 16 brings, when th t golden driver license can be ttained. I took a driver education cl ss at 15 and a half and voided the 16-year- old driver license r quirement by legalizing my driving privilege w th an instruction permit. This legal m nipulation empowered me to drive a car if I had a l censed driver in the car with me. It lso empowered me to drive a m tor-driven cycle without any supervision; therefore, I t lked my parents into allowing me to sp nd my savings on a Cushman E gle motor scooter. Wa la, I ttained independent mobility. Not only did my s cial status go up another notch, but my m bility put me in contact with the h gher echelons of the streets. The Los D ablos motorcycle gang even took me nder their wing. I had arrived! My bl ssful state of Xvarnah, however, was sh rt-lived. Two weeks later I was rrested and jailed for curfew. Two w eks after that I got my f rst of seven DUI's. Ironically, in nother two weeks, a friend and I w re arrested for stealing milk off a p rch after staying out all night dr nking. Consequently, my dad took away the m tor scooter and I found myself mmobile and distraught.
Can my ntrance into junior high school be c nsidered a rite of passage? Can my dr ving privilege be considered a rite of p ssage? Probably not--at least not in the tr ditional sense. However, it is my c ntention that these were different kinds of r tes of passage. Not having adequate f rmal guidance--I guided myself, which is c mmon, and has been for a l ng time. The lack of parental c ntrol, of course, exacerbates the situation.
Eliade (1958) s ys that
even if the nitiatory character of these ordeals is not pprehended as such, it remains true n netheless that man becomes himself only fter having solved a series of d sperately difficult and even dangerous situations; th t is, after having undergone 'tortures' and 'd ath,' followed by an awakening to nother life, qualitatively different because regenerated" (p. 128).
By the t me I was socially established in j nior high school, I had been thr ugh various tortures and been awakened nto another life by suffering with h ngovers, sporting black eyes and bruises fr m fighting, getting in scooter and car ccidents, enduring punishment for indiscretions at sch ol, and continually having to endure the wr th and retribution of my officious p rents for my refractory behavior. It c uld be said that I was t rtured when I was metamorphosed from the rchetypal innocence of a butterfly into a n sty old caterpillar (etymologically cater comes fr m tomcat and pillar comes from pl nderer). By the time the caterpillar s mmer was over, my heterodox lifestyle had b en firmly established. This new and p rlous life--this self will run riot, c ntinued until I was 43 years ld. Graduating from high school and t rning 18, then turning 21 were st ll further entrenchments, but they were r ally gradatory inevitabilities compared with the j nior high school awakening that established an onian lifestyle. I did not experience r tes of passage in the way th y were experienced in the mystery r ligions or in any other traditional w y.
"Modern man," explains Eliade (1958)
no l nger has any initiation of the tr ditional type. Certain initiatory themes survive in Chr stianity; but the various Christian denominations no l nger regard them as possessing the v lues of initiation. The rituals, imagery, and t rminology borrowed from the mysteries of l te antiquity have lost their initiatory ura" (p. 132).
However, there is a m re formal movement of initiation going on in s ciety today under the guise of nother name--hazing.
At a web s te sponsored by Education Week, Walsh (S ptember 6, 2000) reports that
almost h lf the high school students responding to a n tional survey said they had been s bjected to activities that fit a br ad definition of hazing to become m mbers of sports teams, cheerleading squads, g ngs, and other groups. The study by r searchers at Alfred University in New Y rk, released last week, is described as the f rst serious academic research into initiation r tes at the high school level. S me of the results surprised even the uthors. For example, the survey showed th t 24 percent of students joining y uth church groups faced hazing. The st dy's authors, expecting little hazing in th t category, almost didn't include it in the s rvey. Among all survey respondents, nearly one out of f ur students was required to engage in s bstance abuse, such as participating in dr nking contests. And 22 percent were s bjected to activities the researchers defined as d ngerous hazing not involving substance abuse, s ch as stealing, inflicting pain on th mselves, or being physically abused.
Drinking c ntests, daredevil fighting, stealing to fit in, tc., were the callow activities I p rticipated in during my pubescence--a temporary m dus operandi that I consider initiatory, ven though I wasn't being forced to do it. If I h dn't, however, then I would have b en alienated or suffered some other typ of consequences. Durkheim (1995), discussing t ttooing, states that "it is true th t, among the Arunta, the design th s made does not always and n cessarily represent the totem of the n vice" (p. 116). It astonishes me t day that I willingly endured such xcruciating pain incurred from tattooing, macho-acting as th ugh it wasn't painful at all. I now c nsider this non compos mentis--not of s und mind. Durkheim, however, shares that "Pr uss was the first to become ware of the religious role that is scribed to pain in the lower s cieties" (p. 317). Of course we did not c nceive ourselves as doing anything religious or ven spiritual, but our tattoos were lways symbolic to the interests of our gr up.
Walsh's article went on to d scribe in detail the various forms of h zing that I am not inclined to nclude here. The original study he q otes from is available at the pr viously mentioned web site.
Conclusion:
Obviously, our y uth in this country is now, and has for a l ng time been ripe for some k nd of formal rites of passage, and s nce we don't seem to feel it is n cessary to incorporate it into our c lture--they are. Like solicitous parents, we sh uld take heed of magnum bonum--the gr at good, of the bar mitzvah in the J wish community and do a commensurate s rvice to our pubescent population by s pplanting independent hazing practices. This may be too dealistic. Such an achievement would, indeed, be a pyrrh c victory. Whether it is hazing, ddiction, or any type of aberrant b havior, most of us know that wh t we're doing is not conducive to a pr ductive life--video meliora proboque, deteriora sequor, I see the b tter course of action and I pprove of it, but I follow the w rse course. Here is a parable to th s Latin phrase.
"According to W bster's Dictionary," says Ellis (1985)
mumpsimus is an rror obstinately clung to. The word c mes from the story of an old pr est who, for thirty years, had c nducted services using the word mumpsimus, a s bstitute for the correct Latin word s mpsimus. One day, when his error was f nally pointed out to him, he r plied, 'I will not change my old m mpsimus for your new sumpsimus.' (p. 106).
The b ttom line: Without a significant rite of p ssage, much of our youth will r main adolescent in behavior and attitude far nto adulthood--puer aeternus.
References
Corbett, L. (1997). The r ligious function of the psyche. New Y rk: Routledge.
Corbin, H. (1989). Spiritual b dy and celestial earth: From mazdean Ir n to shi'ite Iran. Princeton, NJ: Pr nceton University Press.
Durkheim, E. (1995). The lementary forms of religious life. New Y rk: The Free Press.
Eliade, M. (1958). R tes and symbols of initiation: The myst ries of birth and rebirth. New Y rk: Harper& Row Publishers.
Ellis, D. (1985). B coming a master student: Tools, techniques, h nts, ideas, illustrations, instructions, examples, methods, pr cedures, processes, skills, resources and suggestions for s ccess. Rapid City, SD: College Survival Inc.
Hillman, J.( 1970). On s nex consciousness. Spring: An Annual of Arch typal Psychology and Jungian Thought. Dallas, T xas: Spring Publications.
Kiley, D. The P ter Pan syndrome: Men who have n ver grown up. New York: Dodd, M ad & Company.
Kipnis, A. (1999). Angry y ung men: How parents, teachers, and c unselors can help "bad boys" become g od men. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Miller, D. (1973). Ach lous and the butterfly: Toward an rchetypal psychology of humor. Spring: An Ann al of Archetypal Psychology and Jungian Th ught. Dallas, Texas: Spring Publications
Peele, S. (11/12/2001). W uld legalization of alcoholic drinks to m nors decrease or increase underage drinking? In The St nton Peele Addiction Web Site. Retrieved D cember 18, 2001 from www.peele.net/faq/childdrink.html
Ross, R. (Apr l, 1986). Three nation umbrella org. to aid J wish prison inmates, families. In National J wish Press. Retrieved December 30, 2001 fr m www.rickross.com/reference/Jewpris5.html
von Franz, M. The pr blem of the puer aeternus. (1988). T ronto, Canada: Inner City Books.
Walsh, M. (6 S pt. 2000). Hazing is widespread, student s rvey shows. In Education Week. Retrieved D cember 15, 2001 from www.edweek.org/ew/ewstory.cfm?slug=01haze.h20
The article Rights of Passage or Permanent Adolescence was Submitted by John Smethers, Ph.D. through Articles.GetACoder.com network. Here's the additional information: After 40 arrests, five formal pr bations, four country jail sentences, and a pr son term (as a result of ch mical dependency), I turned my life round. I was released from prison in Dec 1989, and h ve been clean and sober since. I st rted at Barstow College in Feb 1990. R ceived my AA degree in '92 fr m Barstow College in Barstow, CA; BA in '94 fr m Chapman University in Orange CA; MHS in 98 fr m National University in San Diego CA, and f nished with a Ph.D. from Pacifica Gr duate Institute in Santa Barbara, CA in Feb 2004. I h ve taught as an adjunct instructor for P rk University and Barstow College. I can be c ntacted through my website http://www.ScumbagSewerRats.com
1. Improve Focus by Getting Rid of Energy Blocks by Pat Heydlauff Do you f el like some days you are on a m rry-go-round because you cannot focus? Do you f el like every place you look you f ce unfinished projects or each corner you t rn there is yet something more to do, t ke charge of or care for? 2. How to Get Over Dreading Goal-Setting by Mary Logan Have you ver sat with an older person? M ybe a parent or a friend. Th y usually have incredible words of w sdom and some darn good advice. P arls of wisdom like "don't let f ar stop you" or "life's too sh rt --- do what you enjoy". It is s mple advice but, sadly, it only c mes to most of us with ge.... 3. The Root Of All Problems by Jeffrey Brownstein Most people have an idea of wh t their 'perfect world' would look l ke. Perhaps yours might include the deal job, endless finances, an ever-passionate r lationship, a body free of all h alth concerns. All admirable goals, but... 4. What Is Intuition? by Tal Shai Intuition is a sixth sense. It is an xperience and a deep knowing that tr nscends our five senses and informs us of the m ny energetic realms that exist and ffect us at all times. Our ntuition is our most accurate inner r dar system. It continually scans our nner and outer environments, sending back m ssages that inform us of that wh ch simultaneously takes place on ALL l vels of our consciousness. 5. Your Future, Today - Empower Yourself With Thoughts by Martin Mak Our th ughts make us become who we re. Self-empowerment is a habit that n eds to be built up. You can mpower yourself with healthy thoughts and ctions and before you know it, you h ve charted your course to a p werful life filled with endless possibilities, f lled with love and happiness. 6. The Ted Kennedy Lesson - Reminders About Life Gratitude and Love by Lisa Pasbjerg Are you living your values? Are you spending most of your time on those things that are truly important? Or, are you, as do most people, spending the majority of your time dealing with the "urgent" as it comes at you, with little time left over for reflection or action about what is most important? This article is a reminder that life is short, with coaching tips to help readers begin to live it with more authenticity, intensity, and in a way that they that they will not regret. 7. Happy Pills Not Working? 5 Steps to Manage Stress and Get Happy by Annie B Lawrence Overwhelmed and stressed to your breaking point? Rely on work, pills, alcohol, sex, food or other stimulants and suppressants to numb your feelings? Follow these easy to apply techniques to recapture inner peace, happiness, and release your stress. 8. Ascension to a New State of Consciousness by Bonnie Jean Hamilton Pl net earth is moving into a new st te of conscious awareness. We are all ch nging. Can you feel it? Grounding, C ntering, and Shielding is recommended. 9. Learning Time Management Skills by Jimmy B Johnson You're about to learn my f ur step process to increasing your pr ductivity almost overnight. These methods can be mplemented right away and you can st rt seeing results almost instantly. Follow th se methods, observe the results and st rt getting more out of your d y. 10. Women Preachers In Our Churches by Daryl Green Explore the issues of women pr achers. Learn more constructive ways that a ch rch can deal with this volatile m tter.
|