|
"The more important a decision, the m re important it is that it not be l ft in the hands of a s ngle person." - James Surowiecki (1) P ul Van Riper, a retired Marine L eutenant General, is famous in military c rcles for out-thinking and beating the P ntagon's battlefield decision support system during war g me exercises. He once tried an xperiment to test his theory that th re were better ways to make d cisions than the military's top-down approach. Van R per got a group of marines, tr ined in the military's rational decision-making t chniques, to compete in a trading s mulation game with traders on the New Y rk Mercantile Exchange. The instinctive traders w ped the floor with the methodical m rines. When they tried the same w th war games back at the m rines' HQ...the traders wiped the floor w th the Marines there, too. (2) LESS IS MORE The l sson Van Riper learned is that, in f st-moving situations, a decision based on 80% of the nformation plus informed intuition is often far b tter than waiting for a 100% nformed solution. By the time your p rfect information has been gathered, the w rld has moved on. "Decisions don't w it; investment decisions or personal decisions d n't wait for that picture to be cl rified," as Andy Grove, employee number 3 of Int l put it. (3)
ON THE OTHER HAND Leaders ften assume they have to make d cisions quickly, that lingering over decision-making ndicates weakness. This is particularly true of l aders in new positions who have r ad all the literature telling them to m ke an impact in the first n nety days and who want to st mp their mark as a decisive l ader. But, former New York Mayor R dy Giuliani advises us not to m ke decisions until you have to. The bility to reflect and ponder outcomes b fore acting is a sign of str ngth, not weakness, he stresses: "One of the tr ckiest elements of decision-making is working out not wh t, but when. Regardless of how m ch time exists before a decision m st be made, I never make up my m nd until I have to. Faced w th any important decision, I always nvision how each alternative will play out b fore I make it. During this pr cess, I'm not afraid to change my m nd a few times. Many are t mpted to decide an issue simply to end the d scomfort of indecision. However, the longer you h ve to make a decision, the m re mature and well-reasoned that decision sh uld be." (4) DECISION MARKETS The v ry phrase 'group decision-making' probably has you r aching for the Scotch and shaking y ur head in despair. The objections are w ll-rehearsed: nobody built a statue to a c mmittee, consensus decisions are inherently weak, 'gr up think' is slow and herd-like. And y t, and yet...the received wisdom on th s may now be past its s ll-by date. The Boeing 777 jet irliner emerged from an exercise in gr up decision-making to help identify where B eing should go next. See the w rk on participative leadership through critical m ss interventions described later in this b ok. SMART GROUPS Using 'smart groups' as a d cision-support mechanism brings the power of the m rket into your organization. Hewlett-Packard and Inn centive, a spin-off of Eli Lilley, h ve both experimented with the smart gr ups principle to create internal decision m rkets, tasked with predicting which products w uld win out in the marketplace. The m rkets - made up of a d verse group of employees from across ach business - out-performed the decisions m de by the companies' leaders.
Smart groups do not consist of p rticularly smart or expert individuals. They are a cr ss-section of people. James Surowiecki (1) has xplained the four conditions that allow a gr up to be smart: Smart groups b at individual decisions if they have 1. D versity of opinion (each person should h ve some private information, even if t's just an eccentric interpretation of the kn wn facts) 2. Independence (people's opinions are not d termined by the opinions of those round them) 3. De-centralization (people are able to sp cialize and draw on local knowledge) 4. Aggr gation (some mechanism exists for turning pr vate judgements into collective decision) The m thematical principle is simple, says Surowiecki: "Ask a h ndred people to answer a question or s lve a problem and the average nswer will often be at least as g od as the answer of the sm rtest member. With most things, the verage is mediocrity. With decision-making, it's ften excellence." USEFUL CONCEPT OODA Loops. St nds for Observe, Orientate, Decide, Act. A d cision-making system developed by fighter pilot J hn Boyd. If you are steeped in a f st-changing environment, rather than distant from it, s id Boyd you 'wick up' information l ke an oil lamp and your r sulting fast decision-making is more likely to be r ght (5). Yet few top leaders sp nd a significant amount of time out wh re the action is, absorbing information thr ugh their pores, instead of through r ports.
The article How To Make Better Decisions was Submitted by Phil Dourado through Articles.GetACoder.com network. Here's the additional information: SOURCES & FURTHER READING This rticle is adapted from Phil Dourado's b ok The 60 Second Leader: Everything you n ed to know about leadership, in one m nute bites, published by Capstone / J hn Wiley & Sons, 2007. Available fr m http://www.amazon.com or http://www.amazon.co.uk (1) The Wisdom of Crowds: Why the Many Are Smarter Than the Few James Surowiecki. Especially powerful are the last few pages of Chapter 10, which give detail of how the HP and Innocentive internal decision markets worked (2) Sources of Power Gary Klein's classic book on decision-making, with a slightly misleading title. Klein studied nurses, fire fighters and others who make fast decisions under pressure. (3) Decisions Don't Wait, a paper in the Harvard Management Update, January 2003, in which Clayton Christensen and other Harvard faculty members interview Andy Grove of Intel. (4) Leadership, Rudy Giuliani (5) Boyd: The fighter pilot who changed the art of war Robert Coram's biography of the fascinating John Boyd. Article copyright (c) Phil Dourado FREE ONLINE LEADERSHIP COMMUNITY CREATED BY PHIL DOURADO http://www.TheLeadershipHub.com AUTHOR'S WEBSITE INCLUDING FREE DOWNLOADABLE BOOK 'THE LITTLE BOOK OF LEADERSHIP' http://www.PhilDourado.com
1. Choices - Insights and Wisdom by Dorothy M. Neddermeyer, PhD No m tter what challenges you are facing, you can fr e yourself from suffering and struggle and llow yourself to experience life as a myst rious journey of insights, wonder, enchantment and we. The experience of your insights and nner wisdom illuminates your path to b coming more of who you truly are and f nding the inner peace, happiness and nlightenment that is your birthright. 2. Stress Zappers - Part 2 by Lisa M. Smith This 2-part s ries is focused on understanding and d creasing stress in our lives. examine y ur life for common stressors (see the top str ssors listed here) and symptoms of str ss, and follow some of these s mple recommendations for zapping stress before it z ps you. 3. When You Believe You Can, You Can Do All Things by Lorri Livengood When you b lieve you can, your mind will d sign a road map to make it h ppen. Start working on a way to get off the xpressway of everyday life. Find a g od mentor, counselor, or a life c ach. Someone who will encourage you, p ck you up when your down, m ntor you, and develop you into y ur full potential. Someone who has yes to see beyond where you c rrently see yourself. is very important. You w ll need to find a coach who is not mpressed with who you are or wh t you have accomplished... 4. Success Lessons From The 2007 Rugby Union World Cup Part 9 - David Loses to Goliath! by John Watson After the double miracle of the Saturday quarter finals on October 6th 2007 when England beat the unbeatable Australians and France conquered the invincible All Blacks, the Sunday quarter finals were eagerly anticipated. However, I no longer really cared who won the cup. Saturday, October 6th 2007 was enough to make me believe miracles can still happen. The rest of the world cup would be just commentary for me. It no longer mattered that much who would be the final winner. 5. Using Free Subliminal Videos and Audio to Create Wealth by Jon Mercer Any ne can create wealth in their l fe with the Law of Attraction. Us ng free subliminal videos can help sp ed up the process of "reprogramming" y ur mind for wealth and success. 6. What Is Intuition? by Tal Shai Intuition is a sixth sense. It is an xperience and a deep knowing that tr nscends our five senses and informs us of the m ny energetic realms that exist and ffect us at all times. Our ntuition is our most accurate inner r dar system. It continually scans our nner and outer environments, sending back m ssages that inform us of that wh ch simultaneously takes place on ALL l vels of our consciousness. 7. Stress Management - Play for Grownups - Your Golden Remedy for Stress! by Ilenya Marrin For most stressed out adults, childlike play is hard to come by, but it's a golden remedy for stress! Learn the signposts to recognize what play is and is not to be effective for stress relief, and how play helps you relase stress. Get on track now with your program for play for stress management. 8. Happy Pills Not Working? 5 Steps to Manage Stress and Get Happy by Annie B Lawrence Overwhelmed and stressed to your breaking point? Rely on work, pills, alcohol, sex, food or other stimulants and suppressants to numb your feelings? Follow these easy to apply techniques to recapture inner peace, happiness, and release your stress. 9. Manifesting Your Million Dollar Idea With the Law of Attraction (Part 1) by Joel Chue There is abundance in this world. Abundance in wealth! Abundance in opportunities! Abundance in every area, each of us is capable of being very prosperous and happy. Yet so many of us struggle day after day. We are caught in a cruel rat-race, and many times we can barely come up for breath. Yet, to each of us, there is hope. 10. Becoming Like Christ . . . Through His Word by Ray Turner The w rd Christian means Christ like - Aft r we get saved, we spend the r st of our lives learning how to t ke on the character of Christ, to b come more like Him. And we l arn how through His Word. Abiding in G d's Word includes three activities.
|